How to Choose Bourbon | Maryville Shopping Guide

October 3, 2026

How to Choose Bourbon: A Simple Guide for Your Next Bottle

Learning how to choose bourbon does not have to feel like homework. A few clear questions can help you narrow the shelf and find a bottle that suits your taste.

Start with how you plan to use it. Then think about flavor, strength, and price. Whether you want a gift or a bottle for cocktails, this guide will help you shop with a plan.

Decide how you will serve it

Will you sip your bourbon, pour it over ice, or mix it into a drink? Each use gives you a different place to start.

For sipping, look for flavors you already enjoy. You might like notes of vanilla, caramel, spice, or oak. These tasting notes describe flavors and aromas; they do not necessarily mean those ingredients were added.

For cocktails, think about the full drink. A bourbon for an Old Fashioned needs to work with sugar and bitters. One for a tall mixed drink needs to suit the mixer you plan to use.

You do not need a rare bottle for a good cocktail. Choose something that fits your budget and the way you will serve it.

Use flavor notes as clues

Words on a shelf tag can help, but they are not promises. Two people may notice different things in the same glass.

If you like warm, sweet-smelling flavors, look for notes such as vanilla or toffee. If you prefer a bolder taste, look for spice or oak. You can also use a bottle you already know as a reference.

For example, tell the store team: “I liked this bourbon, but I want something with less oak.” That is more helpful than asking for the best bottle on the shelf.

Read the strength on the label

Check the alcohol by volume, or ABV. This tells you the share of alcohol in the bottle. Compare that number across your options so you know when one is much stronger than another.

A higher number does not mean a better bourbon. It means a stronger spirit. Your taste and planned use matter more than chasing the highest strength.

If you are trying an unfamiliar bottle, start with a small, measured pour. You can explore the aroma and taste without filling the glass.

Set your budget before you browse

It is easy to get drawn to a striking bottle or a hard-to-find name. Instead, decide what you want to spend before you shop.

Share your price range and say whether it includes tax. Then compare bottles within that range. A clear budget helps you focus on what fits your needs.

Also check the bottle size. Two similar prices may cover different amounts, so the shelf price alone may not tell the full story.

Buying bourbon as a gift?

A quick bit of research can make a gift feel more thoughtful. Find out what the person already drinks and how they serve it.

Useful clues include:

  • A favorite bourbon brand or bottle.
  • A preference for sipping or mixed drinks.
  • Flavors they like, such as oak or spice.
  • Whether they enjoy trying something new.

If you cannot find those details, keep the choice simple. Ask about options in your budget and avoid assuming that a stronger or more costly bottle is the better gift.

Bring three details to the store

Before you leave home, note your budget, planned use, and one flavor you like. That short list can make your next bourbon purchase much easier.

Explore our spirits page and online shop to start browsing. Then visit The Wine & Spirits Cellar in Maryville to choose your next bottle.

Looking for a specific bourbon? Contact the store to check current availability.

For adults 21 and older. Please enjoy responsibly.